Policy criticism
The text of this post is on X; follow the source link to read it.
Feb 26, 2025 · Posts on X (state legislators) · policy criticism; policy discussion; Law · Source

CSIP score −0.10 (approximate range −0.13 to −0.08, which understates the uncertainty); negative is left of the scale’s centre, positive right. From 0 donors and 297 roll calls.
CSIP places every official on one left–right scale estimated from roll-call votes, campaign donations and the text of statements; 0 is the centre of the scale, not a definition of moderate. The share says where Nolz sits among State House Republicans, not how far from the centre.
5 measures against the South Dakota House. 97% of the 37 bills Nolz sponsored got out of committee, in the top 5% of the South Dakota House. Nolz reported $1,250 in the 2024 cycle, in the bottom quarter of State House Republicans (median $9,081).
The measures on which Nolz sits furthest from the middle of the South Dakota House, each against the same group, with the CSIP score when there is one. Every number is explained in its own section below.
CSIP ideology
More liberal than 97% of State House Republicans · ± 0.03
Out of committee
South Dakota House average 81% · ranks 2nd of 69
Itemized, 2024
State House Republicans’ median $9,081 · ranks 162nd of 187
Party unity
South Dakota House average 76% · ranks 12th of 70 · 97 votes against the majority of South Dakota House Republicans
Attendance
South Dakota House average 96.6% · ranks 43rd of 70 · 638 roll calls
Statements
3 posts on X
Peer group: South Dakota House. Rank 1 is the highest value in the group; the thick bar is Nolz, the thin grey bar the peer average. The headline is the measure on which Nolz is most unusual among peers (Methods, §08).
State House District 20 (2024): the district as drawn for 2024 · 2 members on this site represent it
24,250 people (±198)
District
United States
South Dakota
| Group | District | South Dakota | U.S. |
|---|---|---|---|
| White | 89 | 80 | 57 |
| Black | 1 | 2 | 12 |
| Hispanic or Latino | 5 | 5 | 19 |
| Asian | 0 | 1 | 6 |
| Another race or more than one | 5 | 12 | 5 |
Hispanic or Latino people may be of any race; the other groups are not Hispanic.
Where it falls among the South Dakota House districts: the centre rule is the median, the edges the lowest and the highest
| Measure | Here | ± | The typical South Dakota House district | Percentile | Standing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median household income | $68,100 | ±$5,573 | $73,400 | 25 | lower than in 3 of every 4 South Dakota House districts |
| Below the poverty line | 11% | ±2.0 | 11% | 50 | near the middle of the South Dakota House districts |
| Bachelor’s degree or more | 22% | ±2.4 | 30% | 14 | fewer than in 3 of every 4 South Dakota House districts |
| Median age | 40.2 | ±0.9 | 39.3 | 58 | near the middle of the South Dakota House districts |
| Aged 65 and over | 22% | ±1.6 | 19% | 75 | more than in 3 of every 4 South Dakota House districts |
| Born outside the U.S. | 2.0% | ±0.9 | 2.4% | 42 | near the middle of the South Dakota House districts |
| Veterans | 7.0% | ±1.2 | 7.2% | 47 | near the middle of the South Dakota House districts |
| Living in rural areas | 35% | — | 34% | 53 | near the middle of the South Dakota House districts |
Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates (Census Bureau); rural share from the 2020 Census.
The figures from the American Community Survey are estimates from a sample, not a count. The ± beside each is its 90 percent margin of error: nine times in ten the true value lies within that range. In small districts the margins are wide, so a gap of a few points from South Dakota may be noise. Shares are of everyone in the district, except education (adults 25 and over), poverty (people whose poverty status is known) and veterans (civilian adults).
These are the Census Bureau’s own estimates for the district; margins on shares are approximated from the counts’ margins.
The rural share counts the people living outside the urban areas the Census Bureau drew from the 2020 Census; it is a count, with no margin of error.
Nolz claims credit less than 96% of State House Republicans. Credit claiming in 0% of 3 statements, against 12% for the average State House Republican; 772nd of 801.
An AI model reads each of Nolz’s 3 statements in the SD 2025–26 session (3 posts on X) and marks the kinds of statement it contains: a personal attack, criticism of a policy, discussion of policy, bipartisanship, credit claiming, and extreme labels. A statement can carry several. Every rate is compared with the average for State House Republicans and ranked among them.
Share of statements carrying each label, the SD 2025–26 session
| Row | Nolz | Peers |
|---|---|---|
| Policy criticism | 33% | 9% |
| Policy discussion | 33% | 32% |
| Personal attacks | 0% | 3% |
| Bipartisanship | 0% | 2% |
| Credit claiming | 0% | 12% |
statements classified
3 posts on X.
| Part | Value |
|---|---|
| posts on X | 3 |
The thick bar is Nolz, in the colour of that kind of statement; the thin grey bar is the average State House Republicans. A longer thick bar means Nolz does this more than peers. Rank 1 is the highest rate in the group.
Nolz used no extreme labels in 3 statements. The peer average is 1.4%.
No extreme labels in this window.
Targets named alongside an extreme label, by number of statements
No targets recorded.
Calls a politician, a party or a policy “far left”, “far right”, “MAGA”, “extreme”, “radical”, “woke”, “fascist” or “communist”. The target is who or what the label was aimed at. The lists show the five most used labels and targets; the toggle shows the rest.
Share of statements per month, the SD 2025–26 session
No month in this window has 10 or more statements, too few to chart month by month.
Each row is one kind of statement; each cell is a month, shaded against that row’s own peak (darker = closer to the peak), with the peak and the latest value written at the right. The top row counts statements. The strip covers every month of the SD 2025–26 session, the same span as the rates above, including months with no statements. A month with fewer than 10 statements is hatched, not shaded: one or two posts would swing its rate to 0% or 100%. 23 months are hatched here; 21 of them have no statements.
Real statements from the classifier’s example set, with the labels it assigned
Policy criticism
The text of this post is on X; follow the source link to read it.
Feb 26, 2025 · Posts on X (state legislators) · policy criticism; policy discussion; Law · Source
Up to five recent statements in each category
Overtly questions a named person’s character, integrity or loyalty, or calls them names. Criticising a record or a policy does not count.
No statements in this category in this window.
Newest first, the SD 2025–26 session
Five statements at a time, newest first; filters apply to the statements loaded so far. Export saves the statements that match. Sources: 3 posts on X.
Law is what Nolz talks about most: 100% of policy statements, 31.5 times the peer share. Peers give it 3.2%. Agreement with legislation needs at least 20 policy statements and 5 bills.
Each policy statement is tagged by the AI model with one or more of 25 policy areas from the Congressional Research Service list, so the shares say what Nolz talks about. The bills Nolz sponsors and cosponsors carry the same areas, so the two can be compared.
Share of policy statements by area, the SD 2025–26 session
| Row | Nolz | Peers |
|---|---|---|
| Law | 100% | 3% |
| Agriculture and Food | 0% | 4% |
| Armed Forces and National Security | 0% | 5% |
| Civil Rights and Liberties, Minority Issues | 0% | 6% |
| Commerce | 0% | 4% |
The thick bar is the share of Nolz’s policy statements in an area; the thin grey bar is the average share for State House Republicans. A statement counts once in each of its areas, so shares can add to more than 100%. The five largest areas are shown; the toggle shows the rest.
Left: share of statements by policy area. Right: share of bills. Areas in order of their share of statements; both sides run from 0 to 100%. Grey ticks are the State House Republicans averages.
| Area | Talks about | State House Republicans, talks about | Legislates on | State House Republicans, legislates on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Law | 100% | 3% | 11% | 3% |
| Agriculture and Food | 0% | 4% | 11% | 3% |
| Commerce | 0% | 4% | 8% | 3% |
| Crime and Law Enforcement | 0% | 11% | 6% | 11% |
| Economics and Public Finance | 0% | 12% | 3% | 3% |
No agreement score.Needs at least 20 policy statements and 5 bills in the window.
Agreement is 1 minus the distance between the two distributions (Jensen–Shannon): 1 means Nolz legislates on exactly the areas Nolz talks about, in the same proportions; 0 means no overlap. It does not say whether the bills match the positions in the statements, only the subjects. Bills Nolz sponsored count fully, cosponsored bills a quarter. Shown with at least 20 policy statements and 5 bills.
Nolz sits at −0.10 on the CSIP scale, left of 0, more liberal than 97% of State House Republicans. Approximate range −0.13 to −0.08, which understates the uncertainty; from 0 donors and 297 roll calls.
CSIP, the lab’s Common-Space Ideal Point, places every official, federal and state, on one left–right scale, estimated from roll-call votes, who gives money to whom, and the text of statements. Negative is left of 0, positive right of it; 0 is the centre of the scale, not a definition of “moderate”.
CSIP ideal point
Approximate range −0.13 to −0.08. From 0 donors and 297 roll calls. Run 2026-11-03T100151. Blue is left of 0, red right of 0.
The outlined dot is Nolz, coloured by its side of 0 (blue left, red right, deeper further out); the bar through it is the approximate range (±1.96 standard errors), which understates the uncertainty; the grey ticks below are the medians of Nolz’s groups. 0 is the centre of the scale, not “moderate” by definition.
The score summarises how an official votes, who funds them and how they talk, relative to everyone else. It does not grade positions as good or bad, and two officials with the same score can differ on any single issue. The ± range is 1.96 standard errors, which understates the uncertainty: scores whose ranges overlap may not differ at all, and even scores whose ranges do not overlap may not differ.
Every official in each group, on the CSIP scale
| Group | Officials | Median | Share left of Nolz |
|---|---|---|---|
| State House Republicans | 2925 | +0.3 | 3% |
| South Dakota House | 70 | +0.1 | 30% |
| All State House | 5338 | +0.1 | 46% |
Every small dot is one official on the same scale, coloured by its own score (blue left of 0, red right of 0, grey at 0, deeper further out) and spread up and down only to keep dots apart; where a group is crowded the dots overlap, and darker patches mean more officials. The large outlined dot is Nolz in every row; the rule is each group’s median. The table under the figure gives the share of each group to the left of Nolz.
Nolz reported $1,250 in the 2024 cycle, 14% of the State House Republicans’ median of $9,081. State filings report no small-donation total.
Campaign money from state campaign-finance filings, as aggregates only; the lab never shows an individual donor. Campaigns must report by name every person who gives them more than $200 in a cycle (“itemized”); smaller gifts are reported only as one total (“unitemized”), so donor counts, donor states, employers and occupations describe itemized donors only. State filings report no small-gift total, so these figures add up itemized contributions only.
itemized in the 2024 cycle
From 0 itemized donors. State House Republicans’ median $9,081.
Each square is one percent of itemized contributions in the 2024 cycle.
| Source | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| PACs and other committees | $1,250 | 100.0% |
Totals say how much a campaign took in, not how it was spent, and they rise sharply when a seat is up for election; compare cycles with that in mind.
Itemized contributions, 2024 to 2024. The grey line is the State House Republicans’ median for 2024.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024 cycle | $1,250 |
Itemized contributions by donor state.
No itemized donors with an address.
State filings report no total for small gifts.
Not reported in state filings.
Individuals who gave more than $200, by donor state
| State | Value |
|---|---|
| Alaska | No data |
| Maine | No data |
| Vermont | No data |
| New Hampshire | No data |
| Washington | No data |
| Idaho | No data |
| Montana | No data |
| North Dakota | No data |
| Minnesota | No data |
| Illinois | No data |
| Wisconsin | No data |
| Michigan | No data |
| New York | No data |
| Rhode Island | No data |
| Massachusetts | No data |
| Oregon | No data |
| Nevada | No data |
| Wyoming | No data |
| South Dakota | No data |
| Iowa | No data |
| Indiana | No data |
| Ohio | No data |
| Pennsylvania | No data |
| New Jersey | No data |
| Connecticut | No data |
| California | No data |
| Utah | No data |
| Colorado | No data |
| Nebraska | No data |
| Missouri | No data |
| Kentucky | No data |
| West Virginia | No data |
| Virginia | No data |
| Maryland | No data |
| Delaware | No data |
| Arizona | No data |
| New Mexico | No data |
| Kansas | No data |
| Arkansas | No data |
| Tennessee | No data |
| North Carolina | No data |
| South Carolina | No data |
| District of Columbia | No data |
| Oklahoma | No data |
| Louisiana | No data |
| Mississippi | No data |
| Alabama | No data |
| Georgia | No data |
| Hawaii | No data |
| Texas | No data |
| Florida | No data |
itemized donors
People who gave more than $200
No itemized individual money.
Every state the same size. Darker states gave more itemized money; hatched states had no itemized donors; the outlined state is South Dakota. Gifts of $200 or less carry no address and are left out.
Itemized, 2024 cycle.
No occupations reported.
PAC and committee contributions, 2024 cycle.
Itemized, 2024 cycle.
No employers reported.
Aggregates only. Individual donors are never named.
Nolz voted with the majority of South Dakota House Republicans on 95.3% of party-line votes and missed 1.2% of 638 roll calls. South Dakota House on average: 76% party unity, 96.6% attendance. Across all roll calls, Nolz voted against the majority of South Dakota House Republicans 97 times.
638 roll calls Nolz could vote on in the SD 2025–26 session, compared with South Dakota House. Attendance is the share with a vote recorded. Party unity counts only party-line roll calls, where most Democrats and most Republicans voted on opposite sides, and is the share of those where Nolz voted with the majority of South Dakota House Republicans. The count of votes against that majority covers every roll call where the majority took a side.
votes against the majority of South Dakota House Republicans
Party unity 95.3%, South Dakota House average 76%, ranks 12th of 70. 638 roll calls in the SD 2025–26 session.
The thick bar is Nolz, the thin grey bar the South Dakota House average. The scale runs from 70% to 100% to show the gap.
| Row | Nolz | Peers |
|---|---|---|
| Attendance | 98.7% | 96.6% |
| Party unity | 95.3% | 76% |
A missed roll call has many causes, from illness to campaigning, so attendance says how often, not why. A vote against the majority can be on procedure as well as substance, and many fall on roll calls where both parties split; the key votes below show the ones that decided something.
25 roll calls the lab flagged as key in the SD 2025–26 session
| Party split (yea–nay) | Why it’s key | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 12, 2026 | Yea | With majority | pass | D 5–0 · R 47–15Democrats 5 yea, 0 nay; Republicans 47 yea, 15 nay | became law · party crossover | |
| Mar 12, 2026 | HB 1051 revise property tax levies for school districts and to revise the state aid to general and special education formulas. Do Pass Amended | Yea | With majority | pass | D 5–0 · R 61–1Democrats 5 yea, 0 nay; Republicans 61 yea, 1 nay | became law |
| Mar 12, 2026 | HB 1326 appropriate money for the ordinary expenses of the legislative, judicial, and executive departments of the state, the current expenses of state institutions, interest on the public debt, and common schools. Do Pass | Yea | With majority | pass | D 5–0 · R 45–17Democrats 5 yea, 0 nay; Republicans 45 yea, 17 nay | became law · party crossover |
| Mar 9, 2026 | SB 219 require that a state agency consult with the Aeronautics Commission prior to purchasing, transferring, or disposing of a state owned and operated aircraft. Do Pass Amended | Yea | With majority | pass | D 5–0 · R 62–2Democrats 5 yea, 0 nay; Republicans 62 yea, 2 nay | became law |
| Mar 9, 2026 | SB 245 create the homeowner property tax reduction fund, and to transfer moneys to the homeowner property tax reduction fund. Do Pass Amended | Yea | With majority | pass | D 1–4 · R 41–23Democrats 1 yea, 4 nay; Republicans 41 yea, 23 nay | became law · party crossover |
Automatically: a final-passage or override vote where the measure became law, the margin was under 10%, at least 10% of either party voted against its majority, or the bill was among the 25 most mentioned in officials’ own statements. Up to 25 per window, most recent first; five are shown. Bars show yea on the left, nay on the right, per party.
The colleagues who voted the same way as Nolz most often
The colleagues who voted the same way as Nolz least often
The share of roll calls both members voted on where they voted the same way, among colleagues sharing at least 50 such votes. High agreement with members of the other party is common on routine votes.
SD 2025–26 session, loads in batches
Nolz sponsored 37 bills in the SD 2025–26 session; 14 became law. Cosponsored 0 others. 97% of sponsored bills got out of committee (South Dakota House average 81%; 2nd of 69).
The bills Nolz sponsored and cosponsored in the SD 2025–26 session, from the official bill records, and how far each got: introduced, referred to or acted on in committee, passed one chamber, passed both, became law. A bill counts at every stage it has reached, so the blocks only shrink to the right.
Counts for the SD 2025–26 session
| Role | Introduced | In committee | Passed one chamber | Passed both chambers | Became law |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sponsored | 37 | 36 | 21 | 17 | 14 |
| Cosponsored | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Ink blocks are bills Nolz sponsored, ochre blocks bills Nolz cosponsored; the figure above each block is the count. Most bills in any legislature never leave committee, so a short staircase is the norm.
of sponsored bills got out of committee
South Dakota House average 81%. Ranks 2nd of 69.
Colleagues who most often cosponsor with Nolz, by number of shared bills in the SD 2025–26 session; the square shows their party.
The score is the share of sponsored bills that a committee reported out or a chamber passed, with at least 5 sponsored bills, ranked within the peer group. Members of the majority party and committee chairs move more bills, so the rank reflects position in the chamber as well as effort. Cosponsorship partners are the five colleagues who share the most of Nolz’s bills; the toggle shows more.
Sponsored and cosponsored, with status and policy area; five are shown, the toggle shows the rest
| SB 225↗ official page (opens in a new tab) | apportion interest earnings from the unclaimed property trust fund to school districts. | Sponsor | Feb 4, 2026 | In committee | Education(model) | Committee on Appropriations Deferred to the 41st legislative day , Passed, YEAS 5, NAYS 3 Feb 23, 2026 |
| HB 1222↗ official page (opens in a new tab) | prohibit members of the Board of Economic Development from having any interest in moneys from or approved by the Board of Economic Development. | Sponsor | Jan 29, 2026 | In committee | Government Operations and Politics(model) | House of Representatives Do Pass Amended , Failed, YEAS 29, NAYS 36 H.J. 371 Feb 19, 2026 |
| HB 1215↗ official page (opens in a new tab) | authorize counties and municipalities to issue a license for a cigar bar. | Sponsor | Jan 29, 2026 | Became law | Health(model) | Signed by the Governor on 2026-03-30 H.J. 578 Mar 30, 2026 |
| HB 1209↗ official page (opens in a new tab) | require employment verification eligibility through the e-verify program and to provide a penalty therefor. | Sponsor | Jan 29, 2026 | Passed both chambers | Immigration(model) | Senate Reconsidered , Failed, YEAS 15, NAYS 19 S.J. 524 Mar 11, 2026 |
| SB 195↗ official page (opens in a new tab) | repeal the expiration of a reduction in certain gross receipts and use tax rates. | Sponsor | Jan 29, 2026 | In committee | Taxation(model) | Senate Reconsidered , Failed, YEAS 16, NAYS 17 S.J. 295 Feb 18, 2026 |
Nolz's personal score is withheld in the 2025–26 term. The part from position alone is +1.0 (90% interval +0.8 to +1.3).
The Lawmark Achievement Score measures how far a member’s own bills get against how far the same bills would be expected to get with another sponsor, step by step: committee action, leaving committee, passing the chamber, passing the other chamber, becoming law. It adds two parts. The part from position is what the member’s posts are worth (the majority party, chairs, ranking seats, leadership, seniority); the personal part is what the member adds beyond them. The unit is one standard deviation of members’ personal parts, and 0 is a first-term member of the minority with no committee post and an average personal record.
From position only, 2025–26 term
90% interval +0.8 to +1.3. Provisional: the Congress is still under way.
Only the part from position is shown: a term of bills says too little about each member.
Posts held: majority party · 1st term in the chamber.
With Nolz as sponsor, 38.1% of the state house’s own bills in the 2025–26 term would become law (90% interval 16.2% to 63.9%).
26 bills sponsored: 26 saw committee action, 17 left committee, 15 passed the state house, 9 became law.
The part from position only: too few bills to measure the personal part
| Part | Estimate | 90% interval |
|---|---|---|
| From position | +1.0 | +0.8 to +1.3 |
The score credits a member for bills that move, not for bills filed: a member who introduces two hundred bills and sees six become law scores below one who introduces twenty and sees five. Each bill is compared with bills like it (its policy area, when in the Congress it was introduced, how many committees it went to, whether it is commemorative or an appropriations bill, how significant it looked when introduced), so an easy bill earns less than a hard one. Every score carries a 90% interval; where two members’ intervals overlap, the data do not tell them apart.
A Congress still under way is provisional: pending bills are counted as still able to move, on the schedule bills kept in past Congresses, and the score will change as they do. With fewer than five bills in a Congress, Nolz’s own contribution cannot be measured, and only the part from position is shown.
A methods paper on how the scores are estimated, and how to reproduce them, is forthcoming.
Volden–Wiseman method
2025–26 term
1.0 is the average member of the state house.
The standard count: the member’s share of the chamber’s bills at each stage (introduced, committee action, out of committee, passed the chamber, became law), with commemorative bills counting least and significant ones most, scaled so the chamber averages 1. It rewards volume as well as success; the Lawmark Achievement Score does not.
A site that has not changed in 90 days. Nolz’s official site had 1 page when last crawled on Nov 1, 2026.
The lab crawls Nolz’s official and campaign websites (weekly for Congress, monthly for the states) and keeps every page’s text, so changes can be read later; it also records social accounts and describes the images Nolz posts with a vision model.
pages crawled
changes in 90 days
“Pages crawled” is the size of the site at the last crawl; “changes in 90 days” counts pages whose text differed from the previous crawl. Sites change for many routine reasons, such as new press releases, so a high count is not by itself notable.
No images from Nolz’s posts have been described.
Written by a vision model and may be wrong. Open the post to see the original. Five are shown; the toggle shows the rest.
No transcribed state floor speeches are matched to this legislator yet.
Transcribed from chamber video or captions by the lab. They are not classified for kinds of statement.
How this page was made. Profile built Nov 16, 2026; site last built Nov 16, 2026. Every number on the page is computed from the sources listed here, by the same rules for every official; nothing is written by hand.
The headline is the measure on which Nolz is most unusual among South Dakota House, chosen by one rule for every official of every party. The candidates are the rate of each kind of statement and of extreme labels, party unity, attendance, the small-donor share, the in-state share and total receipts of the latest cycle, the share of sponsored bills that got out of committee, talk-to-bills agreement, and the CSIP score’s place within the party group.
The builder ranks every measure within the same peer group the page compares it with, and writes each official’s percentile: the share of the group below the value, ties counting half, so 0.5 is the median and a value shared by many never ranks first. A measure’s score is how far that percentile sits from the median (0 in the middle, 0.5 at either end), and the highest score leads if it is above 0.25, outside the middle half of the group. Scores within 0.03 of each other are a tie, broken in this order: votes against the party majority, kinds of statement, ideology, roll calls missed, small donations, in-state money, legislation, agreement, extreme labels, receipts.
A measure counts only with at least 200 statements, 100 roll calls or 5 sponsored bills behind it and a peer group of at least 10. Two things never lead: high party unity or attendance, where most members sit, and a high rate of a kind of statement backed by fewer than 10 statements. When nothing qualifies, the headline is a neutral fact instead: statements classified, or years in office. The wording always names the direction (“in the bottom 5% of …”, “votes against the majority of …”).
Bulk files with the same data for every official:
America’s Political Pulse · Polarization Research Lab